Everything You Need to Know About ROI in Procurement

Procurement teams are always looking for ways to optimize spend and drive more value for their organizations. But today, it's not enough to just focus on cost savings alone.

To really move the needle, procurement needs to think more strategically about how to measure and communicate its impact in financial terms. And that's where procurement ROI comes in.

Procurement ROI, or return on investment, is the ultimate metric for demonstrating procurement's value to the business. It goes beyond traditional cost savings to capture the full range of benefits that procurement delivers, from risk mitigation to innovation to working capital optimization.

But let's be real - calculating and communicating procurement ROI is no walk in the park. It requires some serious skills in financial analysis, and stakeholder management.

That's why we've put together this comprehensive guide on everything you need to know about procurement ROI. We'll break down the basics of what it is and why it matters, and give you some practical tips and tools for measuring and tracking it effectively.

What is procurement ROI?

Procurement ROI, or return on investment, is a measure of the cost-effectiveness and efficiency generated by procurement activities in relation to the costs incurred. The goal of calculating procurement ROI is to demonstrate the value that procurement brings to the organization beyond just cost savings.

As its name suggests, procurement ROI looks at the big-picture impact of procurement on the bottom line. 

This is different from traditional cost-saving metrics, which focus solely on reducing spend in individual categories or transactions.

As a strategic metric, procurement ROI is more commonly used by forward-thinking organizations looking to elevate the role of procurement. Unlike bottom-up approaches, a top-down focus on ROI targets executive leaders with more influence over company strategy and budgets.

How to measure procurement ROI

Measuring procurement ROI involves tracking key metrics that reflect cost savings, efficiency improvements, and value creation. Let's explore the key steps to accurately measure procurement ROI.

Step 1: Define the scope and timeframe

The first step in measuring procurement ROI is to clearly define the scope of activities and the time period you want to analyze. This could include:

- A specific sourcing event or contract negotiation

- Procurement performance over a quarter or fiscal year  

- The impact of a new procurement technology or process improvement initiative

Having a well-defined scope and timeframe ensures that you're capturing all relevant costs and benefits.

Step 2: Identify and quantify costs  

Next, you need to identify and quantify all the costs associated with the procurement activities in scope. This includes both direct and indirect costs, such as:

- Salaries and benefits of procurement staff

- Supplier research and RFP expenses

- Technology and data subscription fees

- Travel and expense costs related to supplier meetings or negotiations

- Allocated overhead for procurement's share of facilities, IT, and other support functions

Be sure to capture the fully loaded cost of procurement, not just external spend. This gives you a more accurate picture of the investment side of the ROI equation.

Step 3: Identify and quantify benefits

The next step is to identify and quantify the financial benefits generated by procurement activities. This is where things get more complex, as the benefits can take many different forms, such as:

- Hard dollar cost savings from reduced prices or better payment terms

- Cost avoidance from preventing price increases or demand management

- Working capital improvements from inventory reduction or longer payment cycles  

- Revenue increases from supplier innovation or faster time to market

- Risk mitigation from improved supplier compliance or business continuity planning

Some of these benefits are easier to quantify than others. Hard dollar savings, for example, can be tracked through spend analysis and contract management tools. Others, like revenue impact or risk mitigation, may require input from stakeholders in other functions to estimate the financial value.

The key is to be as comprehensive as possible in capturing the full range of benefits, while also being conservative in your assumptions and calculations.

Step 4: Calculate procurement ROI

With the costs and benefits quantified, you can now calculate procurement ROI using this simple formula:

Procurement ROI = (Benefits - Costs) / Costs x 100

For example, let's say procurement generated $10 million in benefits over the past year, with fully loaded costs of $2 million. The ROI calculation would be:

($10M - $2M) / $2M x 100 = 400%

In other words, for every dollar invested in procurement, the company generated four dollars in return. That's a compelling ROI story to take to the C-suite!

Of course, the specific ROI will vary depending on the scope and timeframe you're analyzing. A good rule of thumb is to aim for a minimum 3:1 benefit-to-cost ratio, or a 300% ROI.

Step 5: Communicate and track procurement ROI over time

Calculating procurement ROI is not a one-time exercise. To truly demonstrate the ongoing value of procurement, you need to communicate your ROI story to key stakeholders and track it over time.

‍

‍

Create a dashboard or scorecard that shows procurement ROI along with other key metrics like spend under management, contract compliance, and supplier performance. Share this regularly with executive sponsors and business partners to keep procurement's value front and center.

Also, use your ROI analysis to identify areas for continuous improvement. 

Are there certain categories or suppliers where the ROI is lower than others? 

What processes or technologies could help drive even greater benefits in the future?

By tracking procurement ROI over time and using it to guide strategic decisions, you can help elevate procurement's role from tactical cost cutter to strategic business partner.

Common metrics to track ROI in procurement

In addition to the overall procurement ROI, there are several specific metrics like cost savings, cost avoidance, contract compliance and more you can track to demonstrate the value of procurement. 

Here are a few of the most common:

1. Cost savings

This is the most traditional procurement metric, tracking the hard dollar savings generated through better prices, terms, or demand management. Cost savings can be tracked as a percentage of total spend or in absolute dollar terms.

2. Cost avoidance

Cost avoidance refers to the savings generated by preventing price increases or reducing future costs. For example, negotiating a long-term contract with fixed pricing terms can avoid potential cost increases down the road. Cost avoidance is harder to quantify than cost savings, but it's an important part of procurement's value story.

3. Spend under management

This metric tracks the percentage of total company spend that is actively managed by procurement. Higher spend under management means greater visibility and control over costs, as well as more opportunities to drive savings and efficiencies.

4. Contract compliance

Contract compliance measures the percentage of spend that is on-contract with preferred suppliers and negotiated terms. Higher compliance means less maverick spend and greater realization of negotiated savings.

5. Supplier performance

Supplier performance metrics track the quality, delivery, and service levels of key suppliers. By monitoring and improving supplier performance, procurement can reduce costs associated with defects, delays, and stock-outs.

6. Procurement cycle time

Procurement cycle time measures the speed and efficiency of procurement processes, from requisition to purchase order to invoice payment. Reducing cycle times can free up working capital, improve stakeholder satisfaction, and enable faster time to market.

By tracking these metrics over time and across different categories and business units, procurement can build a compelling case for its strategic value and impact.

‍

What to do Next?

Measuring and communicating procurement ROI is essential for demonstrating the value of procurement to the organization. By taking a top-down approach that focuses on financial impact rather than just cost savings, procurement can gain the attention and support of executive leaders.

If you're looking to streamline procurement and drive greater ROI, consider Spendflo's comprehensive procure-to-pay platform. With features like spend analysis, contract management, and supplier performance tracking, Spendflo makes it easy to identify savings opportunities, manage compliance, and measure procurement's financial impact.

To learn more about how Spendflo can help you optimize procurement ROI, visit www.spendflo.com  or request a demo today.

‍

Frequently Asked Questions on Procurement ROI

1. How is procurement ROI calculated? 

Procurement ROI is typically measured by comparing cost savings to the investment in procurement activities. It's not just about cutting costs, though - factors like improved quality and efficiency also play a role in the overall return.

2. What are the 5 R's in procurement? 

The 5 R's are a handy checklist: Right quality, Right quantity, Right time, Right place, and Right price. They're all about making sure you're getting exactly what you need, when and where you need it, at a fair price.

3. What is the meaning of ROI in purchasing orders?

ROI in purchasing orders means Return on Investment. It's about measuring the value you get back compared to what you spend on procurement. Basically, it shows if your purchasing strategies are paying off in terms of savings or other benefits.

‍